Showing posts with label choice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label choice. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

I Know What's Best For Me (or so I think)




In the article, “And So I Chose” by Allison Crews brings up the issue of oppression and choice within the feminist movement. Crews says that after she decided to keep her baby as an unwed teen, as opposed to obtaining an abortion, she “tried to find solace in parts of the feminist, pro-choice community,” but instead she felt she “encountered a response similar to the one pregnant girls considering abortion receive from the anti-abortion camp: I was questioned and I was made fun of. I was told that girl like me were almost completely responsible for ‘the backsliding of the feminist movement.”

This brings to mind the article, “You’re a Hardcore Feminist, I Swear,” where the author recalls an email response to one of her quotes. It read, “I’ll call myself a feminist when … “Feminists”…concede that my decision to groom and dress myself as a twenty-first-century professional woman is every bit as valid a choice as their decision…” Within the movement there is a constant strain between the pull of what feminism itself stands for, and the idea that feminism supports the right to choose. How can feminism take a firm stance on any issue without isolating one group? How can we look beyond what we see as the “right choice,” to accept other women's choices, no matter our opinions, to remain free of judgment and oppressive actions, and respect the right to choose, no matter the choice?

This idea of non-oppression is at the core of the feminist movement. Believing that a choice a woman makes for herself is wrong seems very contrary to this idea. Crews writes that, “Our bodies are our own, our futures to mold. No one should be allowed to interfere with them.” Feminism that supports only one choice is no better than the oppression that feminism attributes to the patriarchy when they try to limit women's choices. Being a feminist means supporting women and trusting them and their knowledge of themselves to make the best decision on their own.

Allowing women to make choices that best fit their lives seems like the simple solution to the “oppressive” opinions described by Crews. The problem, though, is that there has been a long history of the patriarchy influencing or forcing the decisions women make. And while women should be respected enough by both feminism and society to be allowed to decide whether, for example, they would like to have an abortion or to keep and raise the child, it is foolish to ignore the social pressure put on women by society that affects their decision. This pressure can lead women to make decisions that negatively affect them because they feel they either have no choice or believe that their decisions are necessary for them to be happy, despite potentially negative side effects. The fact that eating disorders are so prevalent in our society is evidence of this pressure. Intelligent women, aware of their choices, are pressured into starving themselves, in order to fit the image the patriarchy has established as “beautiful.”

Everyday women are bombarded by images of popular culture, of women who have “decided” to work within the rules of the patriarchy, to fit the mold, despite the negative effects. Britney Spears, who from a young age, has played into the role designed for her by men, though largely successful, has experienced enormous physical and emotional turmoil. The pressure to be someone fits the criteria of what is beautiful, what is sexy enough but not too sexy, what is smart enough but not threatening, what is innocent enough but not prude, is crushing, especially for someone judged constantly by the harsh media. The increasing desire to fit the criteria the patriarchy has established is seen in many young girls’ desire to “be like Britney,” who exemplifies the perfect recipe of what is just right.
Feminism walks a fine line between respecting the opinions of women and their ability to decide for themselves, and the obligation to inform women of the pressure that affects their decisions and can lead to such negative effects.

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Don't Tell Me What To Do



I’m sure if you’re a woman—and even if you aren’t—you’ve thought about what you would do given the arrival of an unexpected pregnancy. I know I have. Thankfully I’ve never had to deal with that particular situation on a personal level but I know several women who have. These women have suffered immeasurably and often without support and are still working toward living full lives despite their imbalanced quality.


“Young mothers need to be supported in their choices, whatever they may be,” (Crews, LU, pg.143). This sentence pretty much sums up how I feel about the abortion issue. But so many people today--a striking number of them women--do not see this issue in the appropriate shades of grey and face it only on simplistic terms. A pregnant teenager should not raise her child; she should abort it. Or, on the other hand, a pregnant teenager should never abort her child, but rather give it up for adoption. These are the sides we are forced to choose between when talking about abortion and parenting, and frankly it’s a lose/lose situation.

Women today are not given the freedom of choice they deserve for reproductive rights. I think the saddest aspect of it all is the massive guilt so many women feel after deciding to have an abortion, despite their reasoning. The emotional trauma of discovering an unwanted pregnancy and the decision making process that accompanies it is severely unrated. In Inga Muscio’s Abortion, Vacuum Cleaners, and the Power Within, Muscio talks about how healing is left up to the doctors, that our society is trained to believe that the only way to get better is through another person, usually a man. She says: “Western medicine, that smelly dog who farts across the house and we just don’t have the heart to put out of its misery, is based on a law opposite the one the rest of the universe goes by, namely, Healing Has Nothing To Do With You; It’s Something Only Your Doctor Can Control,” (pg.115, LU). And in our culture it’s true. We are programmed to look outside for help when we really should be looking in. Because frankly, who can tell you what’s best for you other than yourself?

One thing I’ve noticed this semester is how everything we read about can be linked back to some form of patriarchal oppression. Maybe I just feel this way because of all the reading I’ve been doing, but it’s difficult to ignore nonetheless. One example would be from last week’s readings about constructions of the perfect body. We learned in Higginbotham’s Teen Mags that the ideal woman should weigh less than 120 pounds and essentially have no room for her internal organs to function. “Girls are encouraged to love their bodies, no matter what they look like, by magazines with fashion spreads featuring only stick-thin, flawless-faced white models in expensive outfits,” (pg.88, LU). That right there is a form of oppression. If we’re not oppressed by the media telling us how we should look and what we should think, we’re oppressed by society telling us that we can’t be pregnant before we’re 20 or 25, and that if we ARE pregnant we can’t have abortions. It feels like there is no way to overcome this. Which is exactly why it’s more important than ever before to keep fighting for what we believe in.

I have a friend who is 5 months pregnant and a junior at this school that is judged every single day because she is pregnant and unmarried. When I see her I feel strong because she chose to keep her child. And I don’t feel empowered by the fact that she’s keeping the baby, but rather by the fact that she was strong enough to choose and tell the world to back off. It’s for people like her that I have come to support feminism.

~Paige